Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Philip Mollica's avatar

I love your use of pun-based headers - very creative and humorous.

Thank you for your continued deep-dives that I have neither the time nor inclination to do.

Yet, I love it when you do the heavy lifting for us, and I can just see the finished product.

Expand full comment
NEVERMORE MEDIA's avatar

What you pointed out about the contradiction between the Proto-Indo-Europeans/Aryans being nomadic and being farmers is a good point. It's something that occurred to me, as well. What is apparent is that the Proto-Indo-European had a range of native words that referred to agriculture. Those words were not borrowed from another language, as was the case for seafaring terms, which were borrowed from a semitic language.

There is not necessarily any contradiction here - it is entirely possible that speakers of the same language could live different life styles. Some could have been farmers and others could have been raiders/conquering assholes. There are other possible scenarios that could explain this apparent contradiction.

As for the beekeeping, I might have been wrong about that. They could have harvested wild honey to make their alcohol.

Also, I don't have a degree in anthropology... I do consider myself an amateur anthropologist, but I don't have credentials... yet. I have been taking courses at an online university though.

Expand full comment
45 more comments...

No posts