Discussion about this post

User's avatar
polistra's avatar

Chomsky hits a specific resonance for me. I'm disgusted with his activism for a similar reason related to arrogance vs humility.

I"ve always worked in speech and language, and I always respected Noam as a humble scientist. His pet theory is that the structure of language is a built-in part of our brains. This was always obviously correct, even with the knowledge available 100 years ago, and with recent MRI info it's even more obvious. Noam has fought off constant attacks from the tabula rasa behaviorists and meritocrats who insist that nothing is innate, everything can be shaped by the behaviorists. In these arguments Noam was always properly humble and objective, always ready to listen to opponents.

When he strayed outside his field, he became just plain STUPID. He defends the behaviorist side without seeming to realize it.

Expand full comment
Denise's avatar

I’ve only scanned so far, but a book that blew my mind (I listened and did not read) is White Trash: the 400 year untold history of class in America. I recommend to everyone, not in a way to diminish racism, but to add to what we know about history and our society.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts