Discussion about this post

User's avatar
forceOfHabit's avatar

Found this through Tessa's substack. (I also read Charles, although I admit I'l have to go back because I skipped Blood and Raven). Love your take on their work and the importance of love in our efforts to shape the world.

Expand full comment
Infanttyron3's avatar

I'm biased, as I think Eisenstein is who Sage Hana calls, not often, but seldom charitably, Eisenvector.

That aside, or in hand, like a bird, if you like...this story is a set-up/con job that operates on a simple, new-car sales-pitch mechanism.

Two options:

1) His friend is a 'crazy woman' who maybe wasn't even ill. Believe that and insult the storyteller...or

2) A 'miraculous' event did occur with the bird...so hold onto *your* dreams, as they might come true.

OK, lemme see if I got this straight:

A) Call the guy a fabulous liar, with maybe a trace of misogyny thrown in as a lagniappe (hey, it's a big investment, you really don't want to skip the extended warranty and undercoating package...do you?) or

B) Score one for miracles! Cue up Judy Garland (Birds fly over the rainbow...etc) and

ELO https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6128D8ePWdE (more flying, sorry about SS's formatting)

Inset: Old issue of Analog scifi magazine from sometime in the 1980s...scifi author spends a weekend with Bucky Fuller and they have some wide-ranging convos, one of which is about PSI phenomena. Bucky's take on psychokinesis was 'never saw it personally, but OK, maybe'...and his take on ESP/telepathy was basically 'sure, happens a lot to a lot of people...only problem is that right now we don't have sufficiently powerful or delicate instrumentation to scientifically determine 'how' it works'.

Bio was my weakest science, but the obvious connection is electromagnetism...electricity is increasingly being understood as an important feature of the human body, especially the brain...and...migratory birds don't have GPS receivers but they do utilize magnetism. https://www.sciencealert.com/birds-see-magnetic-fields-cryptochrome-cry4-photoreceptor-2018

Magnetically sensitive avian meets electrically abnormal brain...as much of a meet-cute scene as anything from a 1930s or 1980s Hollywood romcom film.

We don't even have to choose (yet*) between whether the bird is acting selfishly (the brain tumor *could* have been generating a wave or field that bothered the raven) or whether it is acting based on the response part of a reciprocal altruism scenario (thanks for saving me, large creature...forgive the minor puncture wound, but I noticed something behind your forehead that you ought to take care of...no, wasn't any trouble on my end...just glad it wasn't one of those thorns-in-a-lion's-paw scene...had a cousin who didn't survive one of those jobs...ugh, that's gross...glad I could help...you're welcome).

*If humans and birds survive, we might someday have instruments delicate and powerful enough to let us to have a confident guess between the selfish & altruistic options...on a bird by bird basis even. Paging United Airlines passenger Tenuta: white courtesy telephone, please. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vknNzCtR954

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qUVeY3FTk0

Laugh in the sunshine...Sing, cry in the dark...Fly through the night

Sleep in the stars...Don't you cry...Dry your eyes on the wind

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts